‘Enshittification’ was the Macquarie Dictionary’s word of the year in 2024, one many of us instantly related to. As the competitive free market grows exponentially, providing us with a confusing array of products to choose from in nearly every niche, companies have had to make efficiencies simply to maintain the same levels of profit as before. This effect is seen starkly in publishing, although I want to stress in this very first paragraph that I’m NOT talking about the enshittification of books in terms of their writing.
I believe authors put just as much of their thoughts, reflections and efforts into their books as years earlier, but there has been a noticeable decline in the quality of the ‘packages’ i.e. covers, publicity, distribution, possibly even editorial as publishers react to the realities of the enormous market that is books (ebooks AND paperbacks).
There is a simple reason for this that I think it not as well-understood as it should be: books don’t always make financial sense. While publishers’ profits are healthy overall, an individual book can make surprisingly little revenue. I worry there’s an impression that the majority of books released by publishers make decent money, but that’s not at all the case, especially these days. As sales focus ever more tightly on the highest sellers, the mid-list books find their sales dropping, meaning publishers have less incentive to truly invest in these packages.
There have always been books that earn very little or even make a loss. In earlier times, the big sellers would offset the editorial/artwork costs of titles that don’t sell well and publishers’ ability to influence distribution to retailers allowed them to be fairly certain that, averaged across all titles, they’d make a healthy profit.
The larger publishers can invest money in a lovely cover with shiny bits and maybe even sprayed edges, but they often don’t unless that investment is certain to pay off (which means an established author/franchise). They have such large catalogues that they have to choose which titles to ‘push’ more to retailers, based on what they think the retailer is interested in (note: not what readers are interested in, but what retailers are interested in). The books that don’t get this special treatment are subject to cost-cutting measures that can feel half-hearted and being lucky enough to receive quality packaging can also end up being a trap: if the book doesn’t sell as well as expected (and expectations will be higher of a more expensive book), then the publisher will invest less in the second book and quite possibly drop the author altogether.
Larger publishers have been slower to engage with ebooks and Amazon, so the result is a book can have a lot of investment, but still never find a readership (and the author doesn’t get to publish anymore with that publisher – tough luck to them because it really can be a matter of luck if retailers decide not to order a book).
The enshittification here is that we are at a point that the majority of books sell fewer and fewer numbers and the big publishers are increasingly propped up by their biggest sellers (or sure-fire projects like celebrity books). Even a big publisher can’t promise to be able to sell an author’s book, because there are SO MANY books out there. For an author, a big publishing contract with a dream publisher is still no guarantee of a good start if retailers don’t order the book in (which is particularly tricky for romance, because it’s a huge genre that is underrepresented in bookstores, particularly in the UK).
But the larger problem of enshittification most of us are witnessing is on the digital side, in ebooks. Again I stress, I don’t think books are getting worse as a reading experience (aside from something AI written, but I don’t think I’ve read anything by AI – I read typically authors I’ve followed for a long time or debuts through publishers when they ask me to provide an endorsement. AI-written books is a topic for a whole extra post because I feel strongly it’s defrauding and manipulating the reader to generate fiction using a large language model). Books are just as well-written as they always were, but as each individual title makes less and less money, publishers have less incentive to invest in covers and editorial.
Even back in 2022, the drop in author income was well documented. The root cause of this is simply that an individual book – months of work for a human author – is earning less than previously. Now, the revenue from a single title in ebook is so low (particularly when split between author and publisher) that there’s no money to ensure quality control for some basic operations.
An editor might have to take on more books than previously, an editing step might be left out. Covers are getting simpler and simpler, using stock images rather than human artists (and AI as soon as publishers think no one will care). There used to be a strong case for investing in marketing knowledge – targeting keywords and tips for getting books in the charts – but the biggest retailer (you know who) changes their systems so often that it’s almost impossible to keep up and increasingly, advertising doesn’t provide a return on investment either and with no return on investment, there’s no business case to spend money on ads.
Again, romance is particularly hard-hit, not least because it’s by far the dominant genre in ebook format, meaning a huge selection of books for a readership that’s not expanding to catch up (after the big boom of five years ago, there’s a natural slow-down). The lingering misogyny around romance that presents the genre as lower quality already also doesn’t help convince casual readers to pay the same amount for a romance versus another genre (I say casual reader here, because my romance gals and guys will absolutely pay for something they love and you are beautiful people).
There’s also no money for things like legal advice. Contracts are frequently flawed or riddled with mistakes, but with the required volume of titles to make money, employees are too stretched to take the time to properly quality-control contracts. The situation for authors is even worse. The legal fees to check over a contract might end up being more than an author earns for the book in a year or more (I’m absolutely serious here. It’s not unusual for a book to earn less than £1,000 in its first couple of years of life – and advances of £1,000 or less are also not unusual for the bigger publishers). An organisation such as the Society of Authors will look over a contract as a membership benefit, but they tend to pick up so many problems and an unagented author will have no hope of getting the publisher to shift on many clauses the SoA would flag as disadvantaging the author and an inexperienced author won’t know which clauses they have a hope of getting changed.
The digital publishers have nowhere to go from here that we can yet see, but in the indie (self-published) space, the opposite situation prevails. Indie authors are often encouraged to treat their publishing as a business and starting a business means investment. An author packaging their own book (if they have the cash) often packages it beautifully. They can hire artists and designers and create the book of their dreams. They obviously believe in their story, so they want the exterior of the book to reflect the story they love. Increasingly, if an author wants to see their book with their dream cover, sprayed edges or foil detailing or with character art inside – if they want to avoid their book looking shitty – they have to publish the book themselves and be able to pay for it. With all of these services, we’re talking thousands of pounds, unless they have friends in the industry who can do them favours (having contacts is increasingly the single most valuable thing for a self-published author as it used to be in traditional publishing – and still is to a large degree).
I’ve heard of a self-published author in the US spending $20,000 on their debut. You saw that right. It makes sense when starting a business to invest, but it’s impossible to know whether this is a wise investment. Kickstarter is playing an increasing role in the indie publishing space, because then authors can market-test a book idea while also guaranteeing the funds, but as more and more authors use Kickstarter, it’s going to get crowded too and then authors will face the same issues of discoverability as everywhere else.
It’s entirely possible that for me, the better path for my publishing career right now would be to go indie, but I’ll admit I’m daunted by the non-writing workload, none of which I know how to do well (including packaging my books. That’s not in my current skill set, so it would be a massive learning curve for me to create a pretty book, particularly because I’ve always been an ebook reader and haven’t been drawn to special editions myself, so I don’t even know what readers want and I’d risk sinking a lot of money into something that doesn’t sell – like my existing indie books).
I’m also quite aware that by staying with publishers, I’m avoiding learning the skills I really need for a long-term career. All of us nowadays need to learn to promote ourselves, network and market our books – ourselves. I feel particularly uncomfortable with those aspects of publishing. I know most authors do, so again, I’m probably just making an excuse, but I don’t have a business background and having to sell things really gets me down, so it’s a hurdle I’m not sure I’ll ever really successfully jump and it scares me that my lack of sales skills might mean my books, which I love and I’ve invested so much of my heart into, are less successful.
Readers often ask what sale will make the author the most money and while that answer will be different from author to author, it’s generally true that buying a full-price (non-discounted) ebook is usually just as good as anything else. Buying directly from an author I’d say is usually the biggest earner for indie authors, but it can work out as very expensive for the reader (if I were to sell direct, my books would be incredibly expensive because of shipping charges on small volumes). Ebooks are a pretty safe bet for delivering revenue back to the author – ebooks on a platform other than the dominant one even better, because those sales will gradually reshape the market to be more sustainable (since Amazon has started eating its own suppliers).
I don’t know what will happen in the market over the next few years. I know I’m incredibly fortunate to be earning just enough to keep doing this full-time and so grateful for the readers who have found my books and value them, regardless of the packaging. I suppose I would just say to readers: please try not to judge a book by its cover and positioning. Read the free sample, look at the authoritative reviews (although these are also getting more difficult to come by at the ‘shitty’ end of the market).
But mostly readers, you are the champions: the people who keep buying and loving books, talking about them and sharing the experience with friends on- and offline. You are the future of the industry, whatever it looks like.

Leave a Reply